There are many people who looked at the trailer for this and said “bah! Humbug!” I wasn’t a part of that crowd; I openly embraced the idea of re-imagining this classic Christmas story (hey, it beats running “A Christmas Story” for 24 hours on TBS on Christmas Day). I am also not a part of the crowd that believes that the performance-capture technology makes the characters look like soul-less zombies. I thought all the characters in “A Polar Express” and “Beowulf” looked fine and the attention to detail was off the charts. But I’m not saying that I didn’t have my concerns. Ever since they announced that Jim Carrey was cast as the three ghosts and Scrooge, I was excited but I was also thinking: “please don’t turn this into another Grinch”. And by that I mean the over-the-top and wacky Jim Carrey, as seen in “The Mask” and “Ace Ventura”. So went to see it today, and I walked out in love with this movie. I have seen the George C. Scott version, the Muppets version, and the Disney version, but I consider Robert Zemeckis’ version to be the best. It has everything that the other versions were missing and more.
The tale is timeless. It revolves around a selfish, grouchy old man named Ebenezer Scrooge who hates Christmas and pretty much anything jolly. But one Christmas Eve, he’s visited by three ghosts that are to help him realize the error of his ways and help him become a better man.
Many have complained about the fact that this film is way too frightening for small children, but what many of those people don’t realize is that “A Christmas Carol” was not written to be a Christmas tale, it was actually written as a horror story. What’s so great about this version is that Zemeckis nails bringing the horror elements to life, but he still manages to tug at your heartstrings with the Tiny Tim situation. Also, a lot of the story’s famous scenes are presented in a whole new way through stunning CG and some of the best usage of IMAX 3-D I have ever seen. Some of the scenes in this film are jaw-dropping, such as when Scrooge meets the Ghost of Christmas Present. Scrooge walks in the room and he enters a giant, lavish room decorated with Christmas items and the room sparkles with gold, green, and red. I was stunned beyond my wildest dreams, because I was not prepared for such a breathtaking sight. There are also rollercoaster ride scenes in the film that are actually quite amazing and don’t distract you from the original story. One of those rollercoaster ride scenes is when the Ghost of Christmas Past flies Scrooge through a snow covered forest and the city of London at night. Both scenes make you feel like you’re being lifted out of your chair and your soaring around the theater (especially in IMAX).
But on the other hand, the horror elements of the story are present and are quite frightening to watch. There are moments where I jumped out my seat, and ones where I felt really, really creeped out. There was a 5 year old boy with his father sitting next to me and during one frightening scene towards the end, they left the movie. “A Christmas Carol” is rated PG for scary sequences and images, and therefore many 1-6 year olds will not be able to handle this movie. I’m not insulting your kids, but there are some scenes in this film are pretty fucking disturbing. And if you see it in IMAX, it will probably be twice as frightening (since I saw it in both regular and IMAX presentation). Many people will read this and say: “it’s A Christmas Carol. It is appropriate for my 4 year old. How bad can it be?” For your four year-old, pretty bad.
Another great feature of the performance capture is the transformation of the actors. Jim Carrey is absolutely amazing as Scrooge and the three ghosts. With Scrooge, Carrey uses Scrooge’s physicality to his full advantage. He lurches forward, creepily moves his fingers, and talks in a bitter fashion. You forget it is Jim Carrey after 30 seconds. He also plays the three ghosts brilliantly, especially the Ghost of Christmas Present. Gary Oldman also does an incredible job as Bob Cratchit and the ghost of Jacob Marley.
Now, there is one particular scene from the film that I did not like. When the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come chases after Scrooge, Scrooge is shrunken and then has the squeaky voice. That scene is played for laughs but I did not care for it. I felt it was unnecessary and it just wasn’t that funny.
Overall, “A Christmas Carol” delivers on everything I wanted from the film and it gives me a new sense of appreciation for the classic tale. The performance capture technology and the IMAX 3-D make a great combination, and it takes you on the ride of a lifetime. Although it’s not for the little ones, this movie will delight both older kids and adults. And people, see it in IMAX. This is one of those films that needs to be seen in that format. A